In lieu of an episode of ROH On HDNet to review this week I decided to try something a little different. I’ve taken it upon myself as PWP’s resident Ring of Honor fanboy to put together a little assessment of the entire ROH roster. I’ll state what their current storylines are, some things I like about their recent work and character direction, and some things I don’t like.
Some clarifications first.
Kenny Omega and Jerry Lynn are not included on this list because the former, let’s face it, is a full-time Japanese wrestler who ROH occasionally book as a special attraction, and the latter hasn’t seen the light of day since a back injury forced him to back out of a highly anticipated match against Rob Van Dam in TNA.
I’ve included managers because they are important as on-screen characters. ROH are paying them to make a contribution to the product so I feel their performances need to be assessed. The Embassy contains four manager-figures at this point and rather than stretch this thing to monstrous proportions, I’ve elected to consider them a single entity.
Where possible I’ve split members of tag teams up to break down their individual performances, but when it comes to the Bravados I barely know which one is which and they don’t really demonstrate a great deal of difference in terms of character and ring work. One just has nicer hair than the other.
Jim Cornette and Delirious are on the list because they’re the ones running the show. I’d include Dave Lagana but I have nothing but positive things to say for the wonderful job he does directing iPPVs. He is the reason the Dragon Gate USA ones have paled in comparison and is a tremendous asset to ROH.
Got all that? Good. Here we go.
Adam Cole
One half of an exciting newcomer tandem along with Kyle O’Reilly, Cole has impressed the ROH faithful with his athleticism. He is looking to make a name for himself, making the most of any and all opportunities he is given.
I’m liking: This kid is remarkable for only two years in the business, and his high impact, flashy move-set wins over crowds with ease. His match with Mike Bennett proved he’s more than just a hot-tag specialist. Finally, he’s come back from his tour of Europe and claims his motivation levels are at an all time high, and who doesn’t like to hear that?
I’m not liking: After initially finding greater solo success than his partner by reaching the finals of Survival of the Fittest, Cole has regressed, losing all of his singles matches since then. Though I enjoy what he brings to the table, I still think he needs to demonstrate a little bit more of what exactly that is.
Andy ‘Right-Leg’ Ridge
The first man to compete in the ROH Trial Series, Andy Ridge has been hungry to earn a full-time roster spot despite losing every match in said series. He’s been tagging with the likes of Grizzly Redwood and Steve Corino and trying to get in where he fits in, so to speak.
I’m liking: Ridge has certainly improved a great deal from the pre-show act he was a year ago, and even over the course of his five-match trial series he seemed to evolve. He’s cut some pretty decent promos and seems to have a real desire to make it big. His athleticism has always been impressive.
I’m not liking: How one dimensional he’s in danger of becoming. I understand that his nickname is Right-Leg and his increased strength in said appendage due to breaking it years ago is a key component of his character, but he can’t JUST kick people. Using the superkick as a finisher is fine, but he needs to incorporate some regular wrestling moves into his arsenal to avoid seeming bland.
‘Brutal’ Bob Evans
The manager and trainer of ‘The Prodigy’ Mike Bennett, Evans is intent on getting his boy to the top of the ROH mountain, and isn’t afraid to get a little involved in affairs himself.
I’m liking: That he can throw a punch. His mini-feud with Steve Corino has been pretty good because he really peppered Steve with some hard right hands, and took some licks of his own to boot. Most managers are cowardly and frail, so it is quite refreshing to have one that appears to be made of tougher stuff. I also like that he seems to offer Bennett genuine advice and strategy, rather than just collecting pay-checks and being a mouth-piece.
I’m not liking: That he’s such a cliché of times gone by. Why on earth does he need to constantly have an unlit cigar in his mouth? Why does he have to talk like he’s in a Rocky film? Why does he have to just parrot everything Bennett says? Short answer is he doesn’t. He can be effective in the managerial role without having to do those things.
Bobby Dempsey
Perennial fan-favourite Bobby Dempsey is still trying his best to earn a full-time spot on the roster, making the most of his limited appearances.
I’m liking: That he’s still so popular. It truly amazes me. It’s been several years since his huge sympathy angle with Larry Sweeney and the fans are still chanting his name. Kudos.
I’m not liking: Much else about him to be honest. I’m not the type to discriminate wrestlers because of their weight, and Bobby moves reasonably well for his size, but he’s still quite limited in the ring. Until he trims down a little he’s going to continue to be little more than a circus attraction for when the fans need a little comic relief.
The Bravado Brothers
Students of the ROH Academy, Lance and Harlem Bravado have exploded onto the ROH tag team division after several disappointing outings early on in their tenure. Picking up big wins over the likes of Adam Cole & Kyle O’Reilly, the Bravados claim they’re going all the way to the top thanks to the support of their loving grandmother.
I’m liking: The idea of heels believing their babyfaces. These guys flash their goofy grins, wear patterned sweater-vests and talk about their unseen grandmother, making them immediate targets for ridicule, but it’s all done in such an overt manner that it’s a good kind of laughter. I like that they talk about fair play and respect, cheat to win, and then celebrate like they’ve just won the Superbowl and want to shake hands after the match.
I’m not liking: That there’s not much to not like at the moment. I like what the Bravados are doing, but it’s a cautious like. They are still fairly green, and they’ve yet to be properly tested, so it’s not quite all systems go for the Bravado Bandwagon.
Charlie Haas
One half of ‘Wrestling’s Greatest Tag Team’ along with Shelton Benjamin, Haas has found a renewed love for wrestling since arriving in Ring of Honor. He and Shelton are keen to prove the WWE dropped the ball with them and that tag team wrestling is still alive, testing their mettle against the finest teams ROH has to offer.
I’m liking: That Haas has enjoyed some of the spotlight. It’s no secret everybody loves Shelton more than him, but he’s a very skilled technical wrestler and doesn’t get enough praise as an athlete due to being upstaged by Benjamin all the time. In their first few matches with ROH Charlie was allowed to show off more of his game than we’re used to, with him being the one that’s finished off most of their matches.
I’m not liking: His questionable physical condition. In his first match with ROH he looked jacked beyond all belief, raising a few eyebrows from yours truly. Recently he seems to have lost some of that muscle mass, but perhaps some fitness too, as he seemed exhausted in the match against the Briscoes at the 9th Anniversary Show. Not only that, he could clearly be heard calling spots as well, and that’s a big no-no. I hope it was just a rare spell of bad form and that he’ll return to his usual best next week.
Chris Hero
One half of the reigning ROH World Tag Team Champions the Kings of Wrestling alongside Claudio Castagnoli, Hero touts himself as one of the best wrestlers in the world, in addition to his team’s status as the alpha and omega of tag wrestling. Keen to back up his always plentiful words, Hero takes on all comers whether it be in singles or tag team action.
I’m liking: What’s not to like? For my money Hero may be the best in-ring performer in the world today. His striking ability is fantastic, and his extensive training in a multitude of styles from across the globe really shines through in technical matches. When you combine these things with his greatly improved physique, razor sharp instincts, undeniable stage-presence you have yourself a truly remarkable overall package. Oh, and he’s the best promo-man in the company by a long way.
I’m not liking: That damn golden elbow pad. When Hero first started using the loaded elbow pad way back when he was a part of Sweet ‘N’ Sour Inc. I thought it could take him all the way to the world title, providing a way for him to always win his matches without making the good guys look bad. But after three years of it I’m sick to the back teeth. Given everything I’ve listed above, and the fact the only man who can look him in the eye is his own partner, is it really necessary for him to cheat to win all his matches? I don’t think so. I will say this problem is more of an issue with the Kings as a unit though, as Hero has won most of his recent singles matches in clean fashion.
‘The Fallen Angel’ Christopher Daniels
Founding father of ROH Christopher Daniels claims he’s in the best shape of his life, and given his success since returning to the company, it’s hard to argue with him, particularly as he holds the World Television Title. After recently acquiring ‘The Book of Truth’ from Truth Martini, Daniels states he has read it cover to cover in order to learn what he can from it. The results have been mixed however, as a more aggressive Daniels hasn’t meant a necessarily better Daniels.
I’m liking: The ticking time-bomb that is his anticipated turn to the dark side. Ever since he stole the Book of Truth fans have been speculating that its influence would corrupt him and lead to a heel turn and perhaps even a spot in the House of Truth as an ally or replacement of Roderick Strong. It’s a really nice idea, and I hope ROH don’t take their finger off the trigger just because people can see it coming.
I’m not liking: Him as a franchise player. Daniels is the definition of precision. Every move he executes he does so with purpose. His fundamentals are second to none, and he’s one of the most gifted talkers in the game. But despite all of these things I just can’t get enthused about him. I know he’s probably going to have a good match against whoever he faces, but I’ve never once been excited about a match he’s announced to be in, even against Davey Richards. This issue is purely a matter of taste, so I’m not knocking any other part of his game or how he’s being used.
Claudio Castagnoli
The other half of the ROH World Tag Team Champions, Claudio is the most physically imposing man on the roster, standing at 6’5”, covered in muscle, and with freakish strength and agility, Claudio’s only weakness is his overconfidence. He has been more aggressive in his second run with the Kings of Wrestling, and in the best condition of his life, he has to be considered a sleeping giant.
I’m liking: Almost everything he does. Claudio is an astounding wrestler, and I’m not sure if you’ll find anyone with a better all-around game anywhere in wrestling, mainstream or otherwise. How a man can look like him and move like he does I’ll never understand. Though he’s not as stocky as a Michael Elgin or the Ken-dolls of the big leagues, he’s still scary-strong and he normally provides one of the highlights of the night by tossing his opponents around.
I’m not liking: ROH holding him back. This has bothered me throughout his entire career; Claudio is the biggest man in the company and he regularly gets embarrassed by much smaller opponents. He gets monkey-flipped or back body dropped like he’s a cruiserweight, stands there with his hands by his sides while his opponent punches his face in, and generally gets made to look a buffoon on a regular basis. This man is a monster, and it bothers me that only PWG and Chikara seem to realise it. He should be destroying people in ROH without the need to resort to dirty tactics. It’s fine to give the other wrestler some moments due to his overconfidence, but I hate how weak the likes of Brent Albright and the Briscoes have made him look. How often does he win singles matches? Not often enough. I’m hoping with Eddie Edwards as champion Claudio gets the solo spotlight he deserves.
Colt Cabana
ROH’s beloved prankster, Colt’s never met a crowd he didn’t like, taking in delight in entertaining them, usually at the expense of his opponents. While he still uses his unorthodox style and enjoys interacting with the fans, Cabana has demanded more serious competition recently, fed up of brawling like he did for most of 2010. Keen to prove he’s one of the best technical wrestlers around, Colt has been matched up with a variety of more scientific wrestlers lately.
I’m liking: This technical wrestling kick he’s on. Cabana’s greatest strength will always be his comedy, and while a part of me thinks he should always stick to what he’s good at and keep his matches to a certain length, he is an undeniably good mat-wrestler. Nobody uses the kind of holds and escapes he does, and he’s that rare kind of wrestler that makes you smile when you watch him. His current storyline has allowed him to maximise his effectiveness, getting in the ring for five to ten minutes, doing those crazy things he does, having a clean finish, and leaving the ring with everybody happy.
I’m not liking: The idea this will lead to bigger things. I love Colt, I really do – all the more so thanks to his Art of Wrestling podcast – but I’ll never ever buy him in the main event. He did good work with El Generico, Kevin Steen and Steve Corino last year, but his niche on the card is that of the comedy wrestler. I can’t begrudge him for wanting to be a world champion, but in my heart I would rather he just continued what he’s been doing for the rest of his career, wrestling in the middle of the card, making people laugh, keeping his matches brief, and getting out of there.
Daizee Haze
The Haze will forever be linked with fellow Woman of Honor Sara Del Rey, as they are the only two regular female performers in the company. To this end the pair have been engaged in a long standing rivalry to prove who the better woman is. Unfortunately for Daizee it appears that Sara just has her number, defeating her in several encounters in the last few months. She hasn’t been seen since MsChif attacked her with the poison mist on an episode of ROH Television a few months ago.
I’m liking: What she was doing with the women’s division since being put in charge thanks in no small part to her relationship with the man in charge. I’m not one of those people that thinks the women are only there to look good and should leave the actual wrestling to the men, so I liked that Daizee made a real effort to bring the women back to prominence in ROH, with a series of short but sweet matches through the summer. She’s also improved from years past, likely thanks to her regular action in Chikara, and I really dug her match at Final Battle, as well as her decision to dress like her partner Amazing Kong; a small touch, but in my opinion a nice one.
I’m not liking: The never-ending, one-sided rivalry with Sara Del Rey. The two of them going to a draw against each other while knocking off countless other ladies was nice, but since then Sara has utterly dominated Daizee. I don’t like that MsChif defeated her but lost to Del Rey as I feel it should have been both or neither. As the person in charge of the women’s division, I think that if she wants to make a real go of it she needs to bring in more talent to get away from it being a two woman show.
Davey Richards
Touted by Bryan Danielson and many of the fans as the Best in the World, Davey has been on an incredible tear since losing to Roderick Strong at Final Battle in a match where he would not quit and had to be knocked unconscious. Since then he has rededicated himself, training harder than ever before and developing a unique hybrid style of martial arts, pankration and technical wrestling. Though ROH have offered him another title match whenever he wants it, Davey has elected to hold off until he feels he is completely ready, demanding as great a variety of opponents as possible to as to test his style to the limit. Richards claims if he does not win the title on his next try he will not challenge for it ever again.
I’m liking: This path to redemption story. I’ve been a fan of Davey since day one, back when people said he was boring, and I actually became a little tired of him when he began to blow up with the fans. I felt he was beginning to wrestle the same match over and over again, leaning heavily on fighting spirit, crowd dives, and his super-intense never-say-die persona. However since getting decimated by Roderick Strong at Final Battle he’s changed things up quite considerably, wrestling different styles of match against different opponents. I like that in any given match he could attack the arm or the leg, it makes him more dangerous and avoids repetitiveness. His match with Colt Cabana at the 9th Anniversary Show was probably the best of the night and if he continues to stick more to technical wrestling and less to trying to be an MMA fighter, I’ll continue to support him.
I’m not liking: The self-imposed condition that he will either win the title or never challenge again. I don’t want him to win the title yet, but he surely can’t keep this story going until Final Battle… can he? I also don’t want him to never challenge again, so in order for that to happen he either has to win the belt in the coming months or go back on his word, and I’m a fan of neither option. I also hope he doesn’t go back to narrowly beating a 20-count, barely kicking out of everything short of an atomic bomb, and no-selling in every match.
Delirious
After years of crazy shenanigans that delighted the fans, Delirious has transitioned from wrestler to head-booker after the departure of Adam Pearce from the company. Just as his predecessor did, Delirious has elected to remove himself from in-ring competition, either to fully concentrate his efforts on the business side of the promotion, or so as to not create a conflict of interests. Let’s not forget his real name is Hunter 😉
I’m liking: What he’s done with the company so far. There’s been an influx of new talent, and it’s been sorely needed. His status as head-trainer of the ROH academy means he should be able to get the most out of his students, and the Bravados seem to demonstrate this. There have been more clean finishes since he’s been in charge, and some more traditional on-screen wrestling build-up, rather than simply relying on press releases on the website from the unseen powers that be. And he’s surely the man that pulled the trigger on Eddie winning the belt so he gets a big thumbs up for that.
I’m not liking: Several little things, but no promotion is perfect. Mike Bennett seems very much a Jim Cornette guy so I won’t go overboard on Delirious for that. I’ll just say I don’t approve of the way he has been handled thus far and needs some rebooking. I think more needs to be done in the way of non-wrestling segments to compensate for HDNet ending their agreement with ROH. I’m not looking for ROH to transform itself into Monday Night Raw, but to build anticipation for big money matches, they need to have in-ring stand-offs and confrontations, rather than relying solely on matches, the website and pre-recorded interviews. I’m also not terribly enthused about the ROH Academy that he’s been running. I haven’t been terribly enthused with it at any point, regardless who was running it, so this isn’t an outright sleight against him, and you can only work with what you’re given, but aside from Rhett Titus and to a lesser extent the Bravados, there hasn’t been much talent coming out of that training school.
Eddie Edwards
A true home-grown star of ROH, Eddie Edwards has blossomed from a pre-show performer, to a tag team specialist, to a singles star, becoming the first Television Champion last year, and now elevating his game even higher by winning Survival of the Fittest and the ROH World Title in a shocking turn of events. Characterised by his unrivalled toughness, Edwards looks to prove to the world his win was no fluke.
I’m liking: That he’s the World Champion. This has been discussed extensively in podcasts with myself Jerome and Ari Berentstein, as well as on the Double J & K Fun Hour, so I’ll try not to become a broken record, but this was just a fantastic decision in that it created a feel-good moment as New York city erupted with approval when he won, and it was very shocking considering the title change didn’t take place on iPPV and Roderick had just won a match that promised to extend his reign as champion. Now Eddie is holding the gold and he’s got the chance to prove to the world he can be a main event calibre wrestler. He’s not there yet, but I think he’s going to use the belt in the same way as Bryan Danielson did, namely to cement his status through a long string of top-notch singles encounters. I think he already has an advantage going for him in his former reign as TV champion; Eddie looked comfortable with the strap around his waist or over his shoulder and really took to the challenge of being a champion, improving his in-ring presence over the course of his reign. I also happen to think his wrestling style is an exciting one, consisting mostly of high impact explosive offence, with a good measure of high flying and striking, and his expert use of a basic submission hold. While he’s not yet known as an outstanding technical wrestler, would you rather know dozens of holds, or one really effective one? Edwards knows exactly how and when to lock the Achilles on and there’s been a few occasions where he added multiple head stomps, something I think he should utilise as world champion as his own version of Dragon’s MMA style elbows.
I’m not liking: That in order for him to become champion a few loose ends with Roderick Strong were cut short instead of tied up. Daniels’ acquisition of the Book of Truth was a direct response to Roddy as champion, and Davey’s path of redemption must surely end with Strong as he was the one who administered a beating unlike any Richards has received in quite some time. Both of these things can be adapted, with Daniels still joining the House of Truth and extending his rivalry with Eddie, and Davey instead having to beat Strong in order to get a shot at his partner and friend, but I don’t think either works as effectively. These are not Eddie’s fault however. I will say that the shock value of the title change on a house show is a double edged sword though, as people won’t see him win the belt for a few months, so ROH may have a tough time selling people on the idea of him as the champion in the meantime.
El Generico
The Generic Luchador has well and truly bounced back from his year-long war with former best friend Kevin Steen, ridding ROH of his violent nemesis, and his own personal demons in the process, tossing aside his all-black attire and sour demeanour in favour of his classic gear and attitude. Generico has immediately gotten himself involved in the world title chase, suffering a controversial loss against former champion Roderick Strong and multiple attacks from the House of Truth. He remains a top level performer keen to punctuate his personal triumph with a world title victory.
I’m liking: That Generico has remained important. There have been a few moments where it looked as though he would slip back down the card after being involved in the promotion’s top feud, but he seems intent to stay relevant with his ongoing rivalry with the House of Truth. He was supposed to face Eddie Edwards for the TV Title at the end of last year but injuries kept the match from happening, meaning we still have that bout to look forward to, but this time for the world title. Generico really is one of the most underrated performers in all of wrestling; nobody inspires more sympathy or love from the crowd, and he can be a killer in the ring when he needs to be.
I’m not liking: Not a whole lot to be honest. He’s competing in big matches, he’s wrestling well, everybody loves him, though I still don’t think he’ll ever actually win the world title.
The Embassy
After years of mediocrity, Prince Nana decided to cut everyone from the Embassy loose with the exception of Erneso Osiris, bringing in his “queen” Mia Yim and employing barrister Robert D. Evans to ease the load of the business side of the Embassy, Nana now only accepts those of royal heritage in his group.
I’m liking: The dynamic of this new version of the Embassy. Evans seems like he’s willing to talk until he’s blue in the face, and Mia is clearly more than just a pretty… well, not face, as she’s willing to throw a few kicks in the direction of the wrestlers. Ernie is the same old mute lackey he’s always been, but I’ve enjoyed the tension between he and Evans so far, with Osiris shooting him hateful looks, and Evans slapping the back of his head and talking down to him. I’m not sure precisely why I like that, but I do. Nana is still Nana, and thus he is still hit and miss. At his best he’s funny and a heat-magnet. Overall I like the idea of there being so many bodies around only one wrestler, and the fact all of those bodies are trained wrestlers helps things out and opens up a lot of possibilities for the faction down the road.
I’m not liking: As I said, Nana is still Nana, so for every good moment, there’s the same monotonous promos he’s always cut, calling people fat pigs and stinking bums. Nana and the Embassy are one and the same, so I fear the group as a whole will fail to capitalise on the promise they’ve shown in their first few weeks and descend back into the booking quick-sand they became in recent years.
Grizzly Redwood
The Littlest Lumberjack, Grizzly is still fighting to prove that good things do indeed come in small packages, never backing down from a fight against larger opposition. He has been untrusting of Steve Corino’s help, not coming to his aid when he was in trouble.
I’m liking: Grizz is still useful when placed in the right situations. Larger wrestlers can seem all the more impressive when they throw him around like a rag-doll, and some of his offence is pretty good.
I’m not liking: When he wrestles a match longer than five minutes. Friend of the site Ari Berenstein suggested that the match between Redwood and Tomasso Ciampa was poorly received because Grizzly was given too much offence, and that’s his problem generally. When he tries to branch out from being a crash dummy who gets the occasional win with a flash-pin, things go badly. I respect him for overcoming so much adversity in his life, but sympathy does not a top wrestler make.
‘The Notorious 187’ Homicide
Homicide has always been a nightmare for ROH management to deal with, but he seems in an even worse mood since his return last year, making demands, attacking wrestlers and disrespecting authority. He is determined to recapture the world title, and has made it clear he has no friends in ROH and that he still doesn’t like Jim Cornette and the Briscoes.
I’m liking: Homicide is very good at non-wrestling segments. He carries off the persona of a rebellious thug very well, and every time his music hits and he heads to the ring to confront his latest adversary, it gets the crowd going because they know something is going to go down. He also draws a strong crowd reaction almost everywhere he goes, and that can’t be said enough.
I’m not liking: His wrestling. Sorry D, people just aren’t feeling you since you came back. He’s never been a gifted technician, but he had a solid working style that got him by that seems to be lacking a little these days. He’s probably working hurt, and he may be out of shape, but he’s had several months to do something about these things. It may be my imagination but he seems to have gotten even more incoherent in his second coming, and there are times I think it’s just the same old stuff over and over again from him.
Jay Briscoe
The elder Briscoe has always been known as the more successful singles wrestler, something he’s demonstrated in recent months with several main event matches against former world champion Roderick Strong. Jay and Mark both seem to have become frustrated with their careers and the New York fans, slipping out of contention for the tag team titles, and Jay himself coming up short in his solo affairs, causing both men to become more aggressive.
I’m liking: That Jay is getting another chance to shine as of late. He’s an underrated singles wrestler with a good mix of power, striking and decent technical ability. If this Briscoes story is in fact a full-on heel turn then I like it because I’ve grown a little tired of them as eternal babyfaces and it will freshen up the tag division.
I’m not liking: The idea that they attack of the All-Night Express may not be a real heel turn. The Briscoes are great, but after seeing them be great for nearly a decade now, it can get a little old. I don’t think they should be split up, but something needs to change, and I think that should be their alignment. Bitterness over recent losses to younger wrestlers should be the catalyst.
Jim Cornette
The executive producer of the now-defunct ROH TV show, Cornette serves as an on-air authority figure and assists Delirious with running the company.
I’m liking: What he’s done for the roster in terms of promos. Cornette is one of the industry’s greatest talkers, and several talents have praised him for helping them work on their promo-game. I’d like to think he’s responsible for the influx of non-wrestling segments in the last year, with in-ring confrontations, contract signings and more.
I’m not liking: Mike Bennett. It’s heavily rumoured that Bennett is a Cornette guy, so I’m holding him more responsible than Delirious. Whatever he thinks he sees in this kid may not be there, or they may be doing a poor job of getting it out of him. Either way, it’s not working right now. I’m not sure how I feel about him acting as Davey Richards’ personal cheerleader.
Kenny King
The ‘Pretty-Boy Pit-Bull’ has come along leaps and bounds during his tenure in ROH, showing promise early against the likes of Jerry Lynn and Bryan Danielson, and improving his game whilst teaming with Rhett Titus in the All-Night Express. Moving away from his cocky showman ways, King has become more serious as he and Titus seek championship gold.
I’m liking: King as a babyface. Ultimately he’s probably better suited as a heel thanks to his mastery of the arrogant athlete gimmick, but his incredible athleticism means he’s going to be a face at some point, and it’s come at a good time. I truly believe he can be a main event player, and every time he’s been given an opportunity to shine he’s stepped up. Keep doing what you’re doing Kenny, you are awesome.
I’m not liking: His lack of evolution. Kenny is so talented he hasn’t really had to evolve yet, being able to get by on a combination of charisma, athletic spots and his promo skills, but at some point he needs to become a little more technically minded. He doesn’t need to become Danielson or McGuinness or anything like that, but it’s the weakest part of his otherwise strong game and working on it will help him rise further up the card.
Kyle O’Reilly
Tag team partner of Adam Cole and training partner of Davey Richards, the future appears very bright for Kyle O’Reilly. K-O’R advanced to the finals of the Top Prospect Tournament recently, demonstrating his tremendous ability and potential as a future main eventer in ROH.
I’m liking: Absolutely everything about this kid. His performances in the tournament were on par with anyone on the roster and he’s only going to get better. His kicking sequences are tremendous, his submission game is wonderful, and he can fly to boot. His offence his unique, but there are clear elements of Davey and even Bryan Danielson in his style, with many claiming him to be the next AmDrag.
I’m not liking: His lack of success outside of the tournament. He’s a newcomer and he has to pay his dues, but that doesn’t mean he needs to lose every match against established names. The guy is good and the fans know it, so toss him a couple of W’s.
Mark Briscoe
The younger, crazier Briscoe, Mark has also attempted to gain singles gold recently with a few unsuccessful challenges for the ROH Television Title. He and Jay have become frustrated with their lack of success of late, becoming more aggressive.
I’m liking: That I like Mark Briscoe again. He was good for comic value and crazy high spots back in the day, but after injuring himself repeatedly he was forced to ground himself a bit. Many haven’t cared for it, but it’s worked out in the long run, and I believe he’s been at his very best in the last few months. His matches with Eddie Edwards and Christopher Daniels have been great.
I’m not liking: See Jay Briscoe.
Michael Elgin
A student of Truth Martini, Michael Elgin is the House of Truth’s enforcer, demolishing those that get in Truth or Roderick Strong’s way. Though a newcomer to ROH, he has made an immediate impact with his impressive power game.
I’m liking: A powerhouse in ROH. Indie wrestling is full of high flyers and mat technicians, with almost all of the bigger guys getting signed up by WWE or TNA. Not only is Elgin a true powerhouse in a company of mostly junior heavyweights, he can actually go. His work against Kyle O’Reilly and El Generico was exemplary, and he really suits the role of Roddy’s muscle.
I’m not liking: Haven’t seen anything so far to dislike. Seriously, the guy has been awesome so far.
‘The Prodigy’ Mike Bennett
Touting himself for greatness since the moment he stepped foot in the company, Mike Bennett has done a lot of talking and a fair amount of backing it up, winning the Top Prospect Tournament. Bennett has claimed he will win the world title before 2011 is over, but in the meantime has been feuding with the likes of Christopher Daniels and Steve Corino, disrespecting both veterans.
I’m liking: The idea of him. It’s rare that a wrestler debuts in ROH and is immediately a key player. Brock Lesnar had an amazing debut in the WWE by destroying people for a couple of months, winning King of the Ring and then beating The Rock for the world title. Bennett is no Brock, but the fact they’d at least try to do something similar is nice, especially when you look at the more traditional path being taken by Adam Cole and Kyle O’Reilly.
I’m not liking: The reality of him. He’s got the look and he can sort of talk, but he’s not been a great wrestler so far, looking lost when the match strays away from a WWE style affair. I hate that he’s been winning his matches after hitting nothing but his finishing move, and I don’t think he can cut it until he learns to work the middle portion of a match. ROH did him a disservice in touting him as the next Rock, and there are very few men that could have lived up to his hype, but to call him average me be generous. His promos are getting repetitive too.
Rhett Titus
Perhaps the most successful graduate of the ROH Training Academy, ‘Addicted to Love’ Rhett Titus has come along leaps and bounds during his time with the company. In recent times he has moved away from his braggadocios comedic style and become more serious, throwing away his signature bow tie. He and Kenny King are on a real hunt for championship gold.
I’m liking: His ability to step-up to his new role. I knew Kenny King would excel if given the spot-light, but Titus has traditionally been inconsistent, so it was nice to see him do well when given the nod for a program with the Kings of Wrestling. His I’m-not-backing-down-from-anyone attitude has been nice, and his pledge to take wrestling seriously has worked out as his natural athleticism is being utilised more effectively than ever.
I’m not liking: How bumpy the road is. Titus has spent so long being the sleaze-ball comedy wrestler, posing and shouting out catch-phrases, that you can tell he’s fighting the urge to revert to this style sometimes. This isn’t his fault, and I’m sure he’ll lean to quash it in time, but for now his transformation isn’t cemented.
Roderick Strong
Roddy made good on his sixteenth challenge for the world title last year, finally claiming his place at the top of the company thanks to the guidance of Truth Martini. His reign may have been full of controversy, but it was also full of demonstrations as to why Strong is one of the best wrestlers in the world. Since losing the title to Eddie Edwards, Strong has been irate and will take it out on his future opponents for sure.
I’m liking: That Strong got to be champion. He was truly deserving of the role, and he’s definitely among the world’s elite wrestlers, so it was good that he was handed the strap and allowed to compete in the main event. He’s as ruthless as ever, and the latest addition to his arsenal of backbreakers is perhaps his sickest yet. His self-promotion as a life-long winner is something I think should have been played on more. He clearly doesn’t have the voice or attitude to be a traditional heel, but he’s pretty much the dictionary definition of a jock, and people don’t like them, so let him do that
I’m not liking: ROH abandoning some of his storylines. The idea that he was unaware that Truth Martini was helping him was a very intriguing one, especially as he claimed he’d give up the belt if he caught Truth doing so. Yet ROH completely dropped this idea as Strong witnessed Truth and later Michael Elgin assisting him in matches. I also think the belt was taken off him just as he was finding his feet as champion. It was undoubtedly a good decision to give Eddie the belt when they did, it’s just unfortunate it comes at Roddy’s expense and I hope he gets another run with it later.
Sara Del Rey
‘Death Ray’ is the crème de la crème in women’s wrestling, and she has long enjoyed the status of ROH’s top female, long feuding with Daizee Haze and always getting the better of her. Del Rey has also knocked off countless other ladies, notably MsChif and Amazing Kong, and she may be correct in her claim that she has no competition. She is also a valet for the Kings of Wrestling.
I’m liking: Her matches. Del Rey is the best female wrestler in the world and has been for a little while now. Her ability to destroy an opponent is on par with any male, with her powerful kicks, nice array of submissions, and brute strength allowing her to brutalise anyone she steps in the ring with. She just hurts people.
I’m not liking: The fact there doesn’t seem to be an end to this road. Haze was the only other regular lady to compete in ROH and Del Rey has bested her numerous times, as well as obliterating every other woman placed in her path, including MsChif who seemed the logical third pillar in the fledgling ROH women’s division. In fact, she beat MsChif in less than five minutes. So where does she go now? She’ll likely face some of the joshi wrestlers that are coming over for the upcoming iPPVs, but after that what does she do? Wrestle men? What kind of a company would allow such a thing.
Shane Hagadorn
The manager of the Kings of Wrestling, Hagadorn acts as mouthpiece, advisor and negotiator for the ROH World Tag Team Champions. He is a trained wrestler but injuries forced him to move over to managing, with the exception of his participation in a match against the Briscoes and their father.
I’m liking: His work on HDNet last year. Hagadorn really stepped up with his promos confronting Davey Richards and facilitating an Eddie Edwards face turn, and if the feud between the Kings and Wolves had gone beyond a single match I think he would have played a key role. He also has that natural ability to make people want to see him get his ass kicked.
I’m not liking: How redundant he is most of the time. He rarely talks and doesn’t offer a whole lot to the Kings other than referee distractions and assistance with the golden elbow pad. Heels need managers and that’s fine, but I don’t think the Kings need Hagadorn.
Shelton Benjamin
The other half of ‘Wrestling’s Greatest Tag Team’, Shelton Benjamin and Charlie Haas arrived in ROH keen to prove tag team wrestling was still alive and that the WWE dropped the ball with them. They have defeated the likes of the Kings of Wrestling, The Briscoes and the All-Night Express already and seem intent on capturing the ROH World Tag Team Titles.
I’m liking: Shelton is still Shelton. He’s capable of those ooh and aah moments that made the Money in the Bank match a must-see every year, and he’s still busting those out in ROH, as well as showing off his strong amateur wrestling game.
I’m not liking: Don’t ask me why, but I get this vibe that Shelton feels he’s above the ROH wrestlers, more so than Charlie. It’s up for debate whether or not he is above them, but he just doesn’t seem to want to relinquish control of matches that much. He had a WWE dark match recently and seemed to be optimistic that he’ll be heading back there soon, so I don’t like the idea of them bailing on ROH after they’ve been pushed so hard, but I guess that was always going to be a gamble.
Steve Corino
The King of Old School is on a mission to cleanse his soul after claiming responsibility for what happened to Kevin Steen last year. Corino now wants to give back to the younger generation so that they don’t end up like him, acting as an advisor in the Top Prospect Tournament and taking issue with the cocky young Mike Bennett. He is struggling to resist his dastardly ways though.
I’m liking: The idea that Corino can predict heel turns and shady characters due to his wealth of experience with both. I also think this story comes from a heartfelt place and he truly does want to assist the new generation.
I’m not liking: The risk of repetition. This is only the most minor of gripes right now, but he’s saying the same things over and over and I’m weary of things becoming tiresome.
Tomasso Ciampa
Prince Nana’s latest ‘Project’, Ciampa is allegedly of Sicilian royal heritage, making him a perfect fit for the new Embassy. Ciampa has made an immediate impact with his devastating finisher and is undefeated so far.
I’m liking: A whole lot about him. He has a good look, he’s ripped, he’s got leaping ability, his finisher is superb, and I like the way he takes his sweet time getting to the ring, making the fans wait for him. Though I haven’t seen an awful lot from him yet, I’ve liked what I have seen.
I’m not liking: The idea that he could be a bust. I want so much to believe the Embassy has become awesome again, and I’ve liked Ciampa’s limited appearances, but word coming out of New York is that he wasn’t so hot, though that may not have been his fault.
Truth Martini
The enigmatic leader of the mysterious House of Truth, Martini teaches his philosophies to students through the Book of Truth. He also acts as the life intervention expert of Roderick Strong, guiding him all the way to the top and the world title last year. He is currently seeking a student worthy of a regular presence in the House alongside Strong and Michael Elgin.
I’m liking: The idea of him having so many secret recruits that he can test. The concept of them having to audition is nice, and the idea that they get destroyed by Elgin if Truth doesn’t approve is even nicer. I hope it leads somewhere good.
I’m not liking: His promos. Jerome assures me the guy is good in AAW, but I’m yet to be impressed by him in ROH. His voice annoys me, his glasses are ridiculous, and his drivel is nonsensical at the best of times.
So there you have it, my honest thoughts about the entire ROH Roster. Knowing my luck they’ll add about four new people next week and make this redundant, but hey, it was fun. Didn’t realise it would end up being this long when I started either, apologies to anyone who stuck with it, and if you didn’t, no Christmas cards for you.
Plugs
– Check out the hate-filled podcast Jerome, Ari and I took part in last week. It’s mostly concerned with discussing Eddie Edwards as world champion and the results of Defy or Deny and Manhatten Mayhem IV, but there’s some good old fashioned TNA and Mike Bennett bashing for good measure.
– Be on the look out for the debut of a PWP trio greater than any that have stepped foot in a Chikara ring…
– Speaking of Chikara, Justin’s break-down of the King of Trios is awesome.